Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing the menu at Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie in Brooklyn, NY. This women-owned bakery offers a unique twist on traditional key lime pie by freezing mini pies and dipping them in chocolate. Customers rave about the refreshing, tart, and oh-so-delicious flavors. With options like the classic chocolate-covered swingle, raspberry-filled swingle, and white chocolate key lime pie, there is something for every palate. The buttery graham cracker crust paired with the creamy, smooth key lime filling creates the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness. The outdoor seating and communal picnic tables add to the charm of this grab-and-go spot, making it a must-visit destination in Red Hook. Don't miss out on this portable dessert experience that will leave you daydreaming about your next visit.
Our Famous Key Lime Pies
" Pie
This is where it all started. We bake a hand-formed Graham crumb and butter crust and fill it with our key lime custard using % fresh-squeezed key lime juice. Typically serves .
" Single-Serve Tart
A single-serve version individually packaged. Throw a few in the freezer to satisfy those key lime urges.
Box Of Tarts Pie
Five over Five. Eat a few now, freeze the rest for later or share.
The Classic Swingle
Our coveted -inch tart, frozen upon a stick and hand-dipped in rich Belcolade chocolate, thinned with organic cocoa butter from our friends at Rakka Chocolate.
The Raspberry Swingle
Same as the Classic with an added layer of rich raspberry puree.
The Raspberry Blonde Swingle
Our Raspberry Swingle hand-dipped in Belcolade Belgian white chocolate.
La Victoria Swingle
Same as the Classic but topped with a layer of La Morena chipotle puree before hand-dipping in chocolate. Feel the heat.
Our Reknowned Swingles
Farmland Light Whipped Cream
-Oz Farmland Light Whipped Cream
Not everyone can just whip up some cream like Steve's wife Victoria (pictured here), so we're offering one of the premium aerosol brands available. Should be plenty for your -inch pie and little leftover just for fun.