Steve's key lime pie is absolutely incredible! I tried the classic chocolate-covered swingle, and it was insanely good--rich, flavorful, and unforgettable. It's a small joint with picnic tables outside when the weather is nice, making it perfect for a quick stop. More of a grab-and-go kind of place. While you're there, make a day of it by visiting nearby spots like Strong Rope Brewery, Red Hook Cidery, or Red Hook Winery, all just steps away! Definitely stopping here every-time I'm in Red Hook!

I love coming here so much that anytime we have family visiting us in Brooklyn - I feel it my duty to take them here. The key lime pie here is refreshing, tart, and oh so delicious. No matter the weather outside, these pies are such a great treat for when you're journeying through Red Hook. If there's a line on the day that you visit - just wait. It always moves super quickly. PS: If you're a chocolate fan - they have a chocolate dipped key lime pie that is so worth trying.

I have daydreams about this key lime pie. So incredibly clever to freeze mini key lime pies and dip them in chocolate. I was actually very skeptical (yet curious!) when I heard of this place/concept, but I had the white chocolate one and was left grinning from ear to ear. My friend and I wouldn't shut up about it for weeks because of how much we enjoyed them.

Came here because social media told me to, and was pleasantly surprised to find out that this place lived up to the hype. I love Key Lime Pie on its own, so the idea of being able to eat one on a stick dipped in chocolate was obviously appealing to me. We came right before they were about to close on a Sunday afternoon, and the line was still going strong. I decided to try the key lime pie with raspberry, which was the right choice. Sweet, tangy, with a little something extra thanks to the addition of the raspberry. Seating here is strictly outdoors as this is a stand, so if you're coming in inclement weather be ready to take your pie to go. It's honestly kind of a beautiful thing to just see folks line up and enjoy a portable dessert together at communal picnic tables on a sunny afternoon. Come for the Key Lime Pie, stay for the vibes.

Food: This is the best key lime pie ever! Everyone I know who has their key lime pie loves it as well. The pie has a buttery graham cracker crust. The key lime filling is smooth and creamy with the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness. They sell three different size pies as well as frozen ones if you're not eating it right away. They sell frozen chocolate covered key lime pies also. If you like key lime pie, this is the place for you! Service: Staff is friendly and packs the pies nicely for transporting. Ambiance: The place is small with tables and benches outdoors if you want to eat there. Most people purpose the pies to go. Overall, I highly recommend this place. It's worth the trip to Red Hook just for this pie!

Saw a video of the spot on TikTok and knew I had to give it a try! We came on a Monday afternoon and we were the only ones there. It was a cute storefront with a lot of outdoor seating. I got the raspberry swingle, which was kind of like a key lime popsicle with raspberry filling and chocolate. It was so good and a perfect treat for a hot day! I'd highly recommend checking this spot out if you're in Red Hook!

What a treat this little key lime pie shop brings to the neighborhood! As someone who doesn't even like key lime pies, I enjoyed this a lot. We arrived 10 minutes before closing at 7pm on a Sunday and there was a line of about 15 people in front of us. The line went by quickly as you just order, pay, and get your key lime pie right away. I noticed he continued to serve everyone until there weren't anymore customers even if it was past closing time. I want to assume it was the owner himself serving at the window (but maybe it could be an employee); either way, he was super friendly and nice. He happily welcomed each customer with such enthusiasm and kindly helped me when I asked for my $1 off with Yelp checkin. Even though a single mini Key Lime Pie ($6) was enough, I also wanted to try the Raspberry Blonde Swingle ($8). It was such a nice balance of tartness and sweetness that was so smooth. While I enjoyed the swingle, I wish the white chocolate option didn't have the raspberry since that was too sour for me, but I'm not personally a fan of regular chocolate. Needless to say, it was still delicious and I finished both by myself. Make sure you grab some napkins as the treat gets a bit messy. I love how it's conveniently located at an oceanfront park and right off the Ferry, so it's the perfect spot to enjoy your key lime pie.

It was less than a 15-minute drive from 7th Street Burger to Pier 44 Waterfront Garden. Luckily, my good friend Jenn found a parking spot. The weather was in the high 70s today. After checking out Pier 44 Waterfront Garden, we decided to try Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies. I informed the cashier about my food allergies. Drinks *Ask for a sample* Limeade (2): refreshingly delicious The Swingle (frozen chocolate-dipped key lime tarts) Jenn: The Raspberry Me: The Raspberry Blonde - Mmm, after my first bite of the raspberry blonde. I am in heaven. One word: Scrumptious Bookmark this spot to try!